Respondent's violations are willful, continuing, and egregious and warrant a substantial penalty.

We believe that the warrant itself was unconstitutional.

Unfortunately we don’t have enough industry in Toowoomba (to warrant the huge cost),

AT&T aided the NSA in intercepting all or a substantial part of communications going over their network. We don't exactly know what the NSA is doing with that data.

The additional six-month penalty may seem harsh, but that's the penalty for three violations. Two independent labs confirmed the three positives, which happened on Jan. 27, Jan. 29 and Jan. 31, and the stewards issued their ruling (on Thursday).

egregious breach of his rights.