The line between protected pornography and unprotected obscenity lies between appealing to a good healthy interest in sex and appealing to a depraved interest, whatever that means,


Antonin Scalia

  Email Quote to Friends   Link to Quote   Create Short URL  Publish Text About This Quote   Share on Facebook, Twitter, and more
  See Recommended Quotes For You

Related

Sex and obscenity are not synonymous. Obscene material is material which deals with sex in a manner ...
WILLIAM J. BRENNAN JR.
Sex and obscenity are not synonymous. Obscene material is material which deals with sex in a manner ...
WILLIAM J. BRENNAN, JR.
In 2015, an opera opened about me and Justice Antonin Scalia. It's called 'Scalia/Ginsburg.&...
RUTH BADER GINSBURG
Well at the time it seemed like a good idea this was a time when the interest rate was a lot more ap...
BRIAN BLACKWELL
The justices have constitutionally protected obscenity in libraries, filth over cable television, an...
PHYLLIS SCHLAFLY
I would draw a really big distinction between competition, or potential competition, and a conflict ...
BILL MARIS
The market needs to walk a line between too little growth and too much growth, between profits and i...
JAMES AWAD
I like to open for a band as it brings on sort of a challenge and it makes things more interesting. ...
KELLY JONES
It is full of interest, it has noble poetry in it and some clever fables and some blood drenched his...
MARK TWAIN
The old equipment wasn't appealing to the eye. It (the program) was thought of as a joke. (Now) we h...
MICHAEL DIXON
We will create life from inanimate compounds, and we will find life in space. But the life that shou...
NICHOLAS A. CHRISTAKIS
Between calculated risk and reckless decision-making lies the dividing line between profit and loss.
CHARLES DUHIGG
Between good sense and good taste there lies the difference between a cause and its effect.
JEAN DE LA BRUYERE
Between good sense and good taste there lies the difference between a cause and its effect.
JEAN DE LA BRUYÈRE
We will accept only whatever is good for India ... The deal cannot be forced on us. The country's in...
C.N.R. RAO
What is a good performance? It lies in the hands and head of a performer... the shortest way between...
EARLE BROWN
The rate of interest acts as a link between income-value and capital-value.
IRVING FISHER
The rate of interest acts as a link between income-value and capital-value
IRVING FISHER
This series captured Austen's interest in showing the feelings of desire between Elizabeth and Darcy...
HELEN THOMPSON
This series captured Austen's interest in showing the feelings of desire between Elizabeth and Darcy...
HELEN THOMPSON
How lucky I am to have known somebody and something that saying goodbye to is so damned awful.
EVANS G. VALENS
It strikes a much-needed balance between public interest and private property rights.
FRANK THOMPSON
People like to say that the conflict is between good and evil. The real conflict is between truth an...
DON MIGUEL RUIZ
Sex isn't good unless it means something. It doesn't necessarily need to mean "love" and it doesn't ...
LAURA SESSIONS STEPP
Obscenity is a cleansing process, whereas pornography only adds to the murk.
HENRY MILLER
It is not in the interest of the German people or in the interest of world peace that Germany should...
JAMES F. BYRNES
We've heard that they're appealing, and that's good, but they've lost a couple of cases. By all mean...
DAMIEN NEWTON
It really comes down to can you count to five, and frankly, I can only count to two?[Antonin] Scalia...
CLARKE FORSYTHE
I hate life, I hate death and everything in between just doesn't interest me.
CHRIS RAPIER
I hate life, I hate death and everything in between just doesn't interest me
CHRIS RAPIER
It's a good strategy, a good manager, just not a very appealing wrapper.
RUSSEL KINNEL
The difference between the '80s and '90s and now is that inflation and interest rates are already lo...
FRANCOIS TRAHAN
The interest rate differential is huge between fixed- income investments domestically and abroad.
MIRIAM TAVARES
Americans are increasingly discovering a direct connection between the quality of their diet and the...
DAVE CARTER
I trained in medicine after pursuing an academic career in the humanities, mainly because of my inte...
IAIN MCGILCHRIST
The difference between pornography and erotica is lighting.
GLORIA LEONARD
[Conservatives Antonin Scalia and Clarence Thomas and liberals Stephen Breyer and Ruth Bader Ginsbur...
ANTHONY KENNEDY
I find that very appealing: the blurring of the lines between what's funny and what's tragic...
RACHEL JOYCE
There's increased speculation that the Fed will be cutting interest rates between meetings.
CHUCK CARLSON
I agree that special interest sections between Portugal and Indonesia can proceed without me being r...
XANANA GUSMAO
Even anti-choice Justices Antonin Scalia and William Rehnquist respect precedent, but that hasn't st...
NANCY KEENAN
Idealism that makes no distinction between areas where our national interest lies and those from whi...
DICK MORRIS
The Bible has noble poetry in it... and some good morals and a wealth of obscenity, and upwards of a...
MARK TWAIN
My interest in the linguistic differences between women and men grew from research I conducted early...
DEBORAH TANNEN
I know I walk a fine line between being a respected actor and being what they call a sex symbol.
EVA MENDES
Justice Thomas, my old boss, got 52 votes. Justice (Antonin) Scalia got 98 votes, ... But Justice Th...
WENDY LONG
The question was a fashionable one, whether a definite line exists between psychological and physiol...
LEO NIKOLAEVICH TOLSTOY
Eventually I came across another passage. This is what it said:
I am not commanding you, but I ...
NICHOLAS SPARKS
To kill a mockingbird. If you haven't read it, I think you should because it is very interesting.
STEPHEN CHBOSKY
I will never forget the vision of Jamie walking towards me.
NICHOLAS SPARKS
As these images were going through my head, my breathing suddenly went still. I looked at Jamie, the...
NICHOLAS SPARKS
You don't have to learn much out of books, it's like if you want to learn about cows, you go milk on...
HARPER LEE
You can't really get to know a person until you get in their shoes and walk around in them.
HARPER LEE
It's important for kids to realize science can be both fun and creative. This really is one exhibit ...
JENNIFER FARRINGTON
Hiring a good designer means never having to choose between form and function.
AMBER LIMBAUGH
The vote shows that a strong, unapologetic, judicial conservative in the mold of Justices Antonin Sc...
WENDY LONG
I know, I know…there’s something cliché about that. The heroine initially wanting to clobber a ...
ANGELA N. BLOUNT
The title of the show is less than appealing to any faithful Catholic. It's not a decision between G...
DAN DEMATTE
It's healthy to have a decent lag time between discs, but if there's too much time in between, there...
CHRIS ANSTEY
You have to have some organization, and you can't have too much, and there is sort of a fine line be...
EDITH WAGNER
And harmony means that the relationship between all the elements used in a composition is balanced, ...
KARLHEINZ STOCKHAUSEN
A Ritual to Read to Each Other


If you don’t know the kind of person I am
and...
WILLIAM STAFFORD
They spend a lot of time resolving turf wars between interest groups. There's not a lot that affects...
JASON WATSON
There has always been, and there is now, a profound conflict of interest between the people and the ...
HOWARD ZINN
The dollar was buoyed as the market confirmed that interest rate differentials between Japan and oth...
YASUHISA ISHIDA
I am a man, and whatever concerns humanity is of interest to me.
TERENCE
Several of the girls at the party had had sex, something which sounded appealing but only if it coul...
AIMEE BENDER
Any effort which wittingly or unwittingly draws a wedge between the people and Armed Forces of Pakis...
ASHFAQ PARVEZ KAYANI
There is a fine line between censorship and good taste and moral responsibility.
STEVEN SPIELBERG
It's not a choice between war and peace. It's a choice between war and endless war. It's...
MICHAEL SCHEUER
When he was in school and worked in the store, I think the interaction between people is really what...
FRANK SKINNER
My nonviolence does not admit of running away from danger and leaving dear ones unprotected. Between...
MAHATMA GANDHI
We expect demand to be high as feedback from customers has shown a desire for a choice between fixed...
CHRIS EDWARDS
In all disputes between conflicting governments, it is our interest not less than our duty to remain...
ZACHARY TAYLOR
These liaisons provide an interface and serve as Crane's spokespersons to address items of mutual in...
MELINDA HENDRIX
Media populism means appealing to people directly through media. A politician who can master the med...
UMBERTO ECO
Courage is a decision you make to act in a way that works through your own fear for the greater good...
DERRICK A. BELL
You're appealing to the organization that found against you to begin with,
GEORGE INNES
Sex, a great and mysterious motive force in human life, has indisputably been a subject of absorbing...
WILLIAM J. BRENNAN JR.
Maybe Gloria Steinem can tell the difference between pornography and erotica at a single glance. I c...
JOANNA RUSS
I find Paul appealing and Peale appalling.
ADLAI E. STEVENSON
To a child, often the box a toy came in is more appealing than the toy itself.
ALLEN KLEIN
The difference between the impossible and possible lies in a persons determination
TOMMY LASORDA
When people begin to define the things that they believe in, based upon the exclusion of all the thi...
C. JOYBELL C.
I trust that you are aware that today’s success is tomorrow’s mediocrity. This means anything ap...
ISRAELMORE AYIVOR
fails to set forth one scintilla of evidence demonstrating that the speech it seeks to restrain crea...
MARK GERAGOS
And the vast majority are occurring as a result of unprotected heterosexual sex .
ANNA FORBES
I think what we had today was a disconnect between the stock market and the economy. The U.S. econom...
ABBY COHEN
I think what we had today was a disconnect between the stock market and the economy. The U.S. econom...
ABBY JOSEPH COHEN
I think what we had today was a disconnect between the stock market and the economy. The U.S. econom...
JOSEPH COHEN
Your true love for God is demonstrated through your ability to hold onto your faithfulness in the mi...
ISRAELMORE AYIVOR
Science means constantly walking a tightrope between blind faith and curiosity; between expertise an...
HEINRICH ROHRER
If time is not real, then the dividing line between this world and eternity, between suffering and b...
HERMAN HESSE
The big difference between sex for money and sex for free is that sex for money usually costs a lot ...
RODNEY DANGERFIELD
The big difference between sex for money and sex for free is that sex for money usually costs a lot ...
BRENDAN BEHAN
It's going to be very difficult for any political group or political special interest to stand betwe...
DAVID HOPCRAFT
The "war" is being fought along the line between sin and righteousness in every family. It is being ...
JOHN PIPER
As a beneficiary of the carried interest loophole, I've seen firsthand the lack of any differenc...
STEVEN RATTNER
So far we have about 20 students that have expressed interest in the GWS major. We also have between...
MAUREEN MADDEN
It makes the operation and the actual procedure more appealing to potential donors.
DR. STUART GEFFNER

More Antonin Scalia

What is a moderate interpretation of the text? Halfway between what it really means and what you'...
ANTONIN SCALIA
The main business of a lawyer is to take the romance, the mystery, the irony, the ambiguity out of e...
ANTONIN SCALIA
What secret knowledge, one must wonder, is breathed into lawyers when they become Justices of this C...
ANTONIN SCALIA
The Constitution that I interpret and apply is not living, but dead, or as I prefer to call it, endu...
ANTONIN SCALIA
Like most rights, the Second Amendment right is not unlimited... It is not a right to keep and carry...
ANTONIN SCALIA
There exists in some parts of the world sanctimonious criticism of America's death penalty, as s...
ANTONIN SCALIA
It's absolutely clear that whatever cruel and unusual punishments may - may mean with regard to ...
ANTONIN SCALIA
The court makes an amazing amount of decisions that ought to be made by the people.
ANTONIN SCALIA
The Court today completes the process of converting Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 from a...
ANTONIN SCALIA
I spent my junior year in Switzerland. On the way back home, I spent some time in England, and I rem...
ANTONIN SCALIA
By formally declaring anyone opposed to same-sex marriage an enemy of human decency, the majority ar...
ANTONIN SCALIA
As a general rule, I do not think it appropriate for judges to heap either praise or censure upon a ...
ANTONIN SCALIA
is to give live-birth abortion free rein.
ANTONIN SCALIA
a serious inability of our political branches to conduct international affairs.
ANTONIN SCALIA
find itself unable to resolve the significant legal issue presented by the case.
ANTONIN SCALIA
Mere factual innocence is no reason not to carry out a death sentence properly reached
ANTONIN SCALIA
A search is a search, even if it happens to disclose nothing but the bottom of a turntable.
ANTONIN SCALIA
If you think aficionados of a living Constitution want to bring you flexibility, think again. You th...
ANTONIN SCALIA
Maybe he wanted to buy a new crutch for Tiny Tim, ... Please, counselor, don't read all these tender...
ANTONIN SCALIA
[The Freedom of Information Act is] the Taj Mahal of the Doctrine of Unanticipated Consequences, the...
ANTONIN SCALIA
The Court today completes the process of converting [Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964] from...
ANTONIN SCALIA
I attack ideas. I don't attack people. And some very good people have some very bad ideas. And i...
ANTONIN SCALIA
In a big family the first child is kind of like the first pancake. If it's not perfect, that'...
ANTONIN SCALIA
But I'm not pro death penalty. I - I'm just anti the notion that it is not a matter for demo...
ANTONIN SCALIA
The American people have determined that the good to be derived from capital punishment - in deterre...
ANTONIN SCALIA
There is nothing new in the realization that the Constitution sometimes insulates the criminality of...
ANTONIN SCALIA
A good, hard-hitting dissent keeps you honest.
ANTONIN SCALIA
Originalism is sort of subspecies of textualism. Textualism means you are governed by the text. That...
ANTONIN SCALIA
I used to say that the Constitution is not a living document. It's dead, dead, dead. But I'v...
ANTONIN SCALIA
Until the courts put a stop to it, public debate over same-sex marriage displayed American democracy...
ANTONIN SCALIA
I think I'm a pretty nice fella.
ANTONIN SCALIA
I do accept that, with - with respect to those vague terms in the Constitution such as equal protect...
ANTONIN SCALIA
Being a good person begins with being a wise person. Then, when you follow your conscience, will you...
ANTONIN SCALIA
If you're going to be a good and faithful judge, you have to resign yourself to the fact that yo...
ANTONIN SCALIA
It seems to be an odd proposition,
ANTONIN SCALIA
If you think aficionados of a living Constitution want to bring you flexibility, think again. You th...
ANTONIN SCALIA
With each decision of ours that takes from the People a question properly left to them - with each d...
ANTONIN SCALIA
And what I would say now is, yes, if a state enacted a law permitting flogging, it is immensely stup...
ANTONIN SCALIA
Some people are inherently likeable. If you're not - work on it. It may even improve your social...
ANTONIN SCALIA
Like other human institutions, courts and juries are not perfect. One cannot have a system of crimin...
ANTONIN SCALIA
I would think the normal assumption is if one person wants that search excluded, that search is excl...
ANTONIN SCALIA
If there's anything you absolutely hate, why, it must be unconstitutional. Or, if there's an...
ANTONIN SCALIA
It's not up to the courts to invent new minorities that get special protections.
ANTONIN SCALIA
I watched 'The Sopranos,' I saw a couple of episodes of 'Mad Men.' I loved 'Sein...
ANTONIN SCALIA
that reliability be assessed in a particular manner: by testing in the crucible of cross-examination...
ANTONIN SCALIA
The counting of votes that are of questionable legality does in my view threaten irreparable harm to...
ANTONIN SCALIA
You could have 50 different states having 50 different regulations ... until they were all litigated...
ANTONIN SCALIA
If you are sentenced to torture for a crime, yes, that is a cruel punishment. But the mere fact that...
ANTONIN SCALIA
Because values change, legislatures abolish the death penalty, permit same-sex marriage if they want...
ANTONIN SCALIA
I do not think my impartiality could reasonably be questioned.
ANTONIN SCALIA
Does it stop being a quota because it is somewhere between eight and 12 percent, but it is a quota i...
ANTONIN SCALIA
The first instinct of power is the retention of power, and under a Constitution that requires period...
ANTONIN SCALIA
I am questioning the propriety – indeed, the sanity – of having a value-laden decision such as t...
ANTONIN SCALIA
Such commands are fundamentally incompatible with our constitutional system of dual sovereignty.
ANTONIN SCALIA
What is a moderate interpretation of the text? Halfway between what it really means and what you'd l...
ANTONIN SCALIA
If there was anybody that has been sort of the social glue of the court, it's been Sandra and I will...
ANTONIN SCALIA
is locked in the heart of the president.
ANTONIN SCALIA
I don't know. I wouldn't want to go through it today, I'll tell you that much.
ANTONIN SCALIA
When dinner is over, it won't be her bones on the table.
ANTONIN SCALIA
They don't have any separate harm.
ANTONIN SCALIA
I do not believe my impartiality can reasonably be questioned,
ANTONIN SCALIA
Let the cancer patients suffer.
ANTONIN SCALIA
I cannot imagine any responsible citizen would have objected to giving the name,
ANTONIN SCALIA
I assure you, I have no agenda.
ANTONIN SCALIA
I don't like interjecting us into a battle between the two political branches,
ANTONIN SCALIA
The LSC subsidy neither prevents anyone from speaking nor coerces anyone to change speech,
ANTONIN SCALIA
Abortion is off the democratic stage. Prohibiting it is unconstitutional, now and forever, coast to ...
ANTONIN SCALIA
A journalistic purpose could be someone with a Xerox machine in a basement.
ANTONIN SCALIA
over my dead body.
ANTONIN SCALIA
You can make an exception without the sky falling,
ANTONIN SCALIA
What will happen is, for every one person who sees it on C-SPAN gavel to gavel -- so that they can r...
ANTONIN SCALIA
Does the deck seem stacked against those who oppose abortion? ... You bet.
ANTONIN SCALIA
If one is to say as the court does today that ALL executions of the mentally retarded are so morally...
ANTONIN SCALIA
the Constitution's refusal to 'deny or disparage' other rights is far removed from affirming any one...
ANTONIN SCALIA
They view this as protecting themselves and their families from a lifestyle that they believe to be ...
ANTONIN SCALIA
In a big family the first child is kind of like the first pancake. If it's not perfect, that's okay,...
ANTONIN SCALIA
The First Amendment has not repealed the ancient rule of life, that he who pays the piper calls the ...
ANTONIN SCALIA
A law can be both economic folly and constitutional.
ANTONIN SCALIA
We have laws against torture. The Constitution says nothing whatever about torture. It speaks of pun...
ANTONIN SCALIA
Mere factual innocence is no reason not to carry
out a death sentence properly reached.
ANTONIN SCALIA
If we're picking people to draw out of their own conscience and experience a 'new' Const...
ANTONIN SCALIA
Power tends to corrupt. But the power in Washington resides in Congress, if it wants to use it. It c...
ANTONIN SCALIA
If I have brought any message today, it is this: Have the courage to have your wisdom regarded as st...
ANTONIN SCALIA
If I had to choose, I would always take the less dynamic, indeed even the lazy person who knows what...
ANTONIN SCALIA
I think Thomas Jefferson would have said the more speech, the better.
ANTONIN SCALIA
Burning the flag is a form of expression. Speech doesn't just mean written words or oral words. ...
ANTONIN SCALIA
Words have meaning. And their meaning doesn't change.
ANTONIN SCALIA
A man who has made no enemies is probably not a very good man.
ANTONIN SCALIA
My family has served the country in almost every major war since the Civil War.
JACK SCALIA
There's a greatness in this country many of the kids today don't know.
JACK SCALIA
I was raised with those principals and values and ethics that came out of the men and women that ser...
JACK SCALIA
I remember fear and I remember the potential of nuclear war.
JACK SCALIA
You gotta take care of the people that are part of the foundation. If you don't, it crumbles.
JACK SCALIA
But this country is a great country and will always rebound.
JACK SCALIA
Because if you have a strong foundation like we have, then you can build or rebuild anything on it. ...
JACK SCALIA
Our firefighters are our last line of defense, baby.
JACK SCALIA
The reward of a work is to have produced it; the reward of effort is to have grown by it.
ANTONIN SERTILLANGES
Mozart is sweet sunshine.
ANTONIN DVORAK
When we speak the word life, it must be understood we are not referring to life as we know it from i...
ANTONIN ARTAUD
If I commit suicide, it will not be to destroy myself but to put myself back together again. Suicide...
ANTONIN ARTAUD
You are outside life, you are above life, you have miseries which the ordinary man does not know, yo...
ANTONIN ARTAUD
Tragedy on the stage is no longer enough for me, I shall bring it into my own life.
ANTONIN ARTAUD
The stage is a concrete physical place which asks to be filled, and to be given its own concrete lan...
ANTONIN ARTAUD
The theater, which is in no thing, but makes use of everything
ANTONIN ARTAUD
Theater of cruelty means a theater difficult and cruel for myself first of all. And, on the level of...
ANTONIN ARTAUD
However fiercely opposed one may be to the present order, an old respect for the idea of order itsel...
ANTONIN ARTAUD
With society and its public, there is no longer any other language than that of bombs, barricades, a...
ANTONIN ARTAUD
Never tire yourself more than necessary, even if you have to found a culture on the fatigue of your ...
ANTONIN ARTAUD
It is thus that the few rare lucid well-disposed people who have had to struggle on the earth find t...
ANTONIN ARTAUD
But how is one to make a scientist understand that there is something unalterably deranged about dif...
ANTONIN ARTAUD
And what is an authentic madman? It is a man who preferred to become mad, in the socially accepted s...
ANTONIN ARTAUD
Hell is of this world and there are men who are unhappy escapees from hell, escapees destined ETERNA...
ANTONIN ARTAUD
The race of prophets is extinct. Europe is becoming set in its ways, slowly embalming itself beneath...
ANTONIN ARTAUD
It is not opium which makes me work but its absence, and in order for me to feel its absence it must...
ANTONIN ARTAUD
Ah! How neatly tied, in these people, is the umbilical cord of morality! Since they left their mothe...
ANTONIN ARTAUD
So long as we have failed to eliminate any of the causes of human despair, we do not have the right ...
ANTONIN ARTAUD
There are souls that are incurable and lost to the rest of society. Deprive them of one means of fol...
ANTONIN ARTAUD
There is in every madman a misunderstood genius whose idea, shining in his head, frightened people, ...
ANTONIN ARTAUD
All true language is incomprehensible, like the chatter of a beggar's teeth.
ANTONIN ARTAUD
It is almost impossible to be a doctor and an honest man, but it is obscenely impossible to be a psy...
ANTONIN ARTAUD
I myself spent nine years in an insane asylum and I never had the obsession of suicide, but I know t...
ANTONIN ARTAUD
Written poetry is worth reading once, and then should be destroyed. Let the dead poets make way for ...
ANTONIN ARTAUD
No one has ever written, painted, sculpted, modeled, built, or invented except literally to get out ...
ANTONIN ARTAUD
Never tire yourself more than necessary, even if you have to found a culture on the fatigue of yo...
ANTONIN ARTAUD
We do not die because we have to die; we die because one day, and not so long ago, our consciousness...
ANTONIN ARTAUD
The theater, which is in no thing, but makes use of everything -- gestures, sounds, words, screams, ...
ANTONIN ARTAUD
There is in every madman a misunderstood genius whose idea, shining in his head, frightened people, ...
ANTONIN ARTAUD
Where there is a stink of shit there is a smell of being
ANTONIN ARTAUD
All true language is incomprehensible, like the chatter of a beggar's teeth.
ANTONIN ARTAUD
I have need of angels. Enough hell has swallowed me for too many years. But finally understand this-...
ANTONIN ARTAUD
We must beware of yielding to the pressure of a spirit of cowardly conformity which proclaims itself...
ANTONIN SERTILLANGES
Written poetry is worth reading once, and then should be destroyed. Let the dead poets make way for ...
ANTONIN ARTAUD
When we speak the word ''life',' it must be understood we are not referring to life as we know it fr...
ANTONIN ARTAUD
Destroy yourselves, you who are desperate, and you who are tortured in body and soul, abandon all ho...
ANTONIN ARTAUD
We must wash literature off ourselves. We want to be men above all, to be human.
ANTONIN ARTAUD
Those who live, live off the dead.
ANTONIN ARTAUD
It is a painful thing to say to oneself: by choosing one road I am turning my back on a thousand oth...
ANTONIN SERTILLANGES
I, myself, spent 9 years in an insane asylum and never had any suicidal tendencies, but I know that ...
ANTONIN ARTAUD
Don't tire yourself more than need be, even at the price of founding a culture on the fatigue of you...
ANTONIN ARTAUD
When we speak the word 'life,' it must be understood we are not referring to life as we know...
ANTONIN ARTAUD
The man who is too isolated grows timid, abstracted, a little odd: He stumbles along amid realities ...
ANTONIN SERTILLANGES
[defines a madman as] a man who preferred to become mad,in the socially accepted sense of the word, ...
ANTONIN ARTAUD
Don't tire yourself more than need be, even at the price of founding a culture on the fatigue of...
ANTONIN ARTAUD
There is in every madman
a misunderstood genius
whose idea
shining in his head
f...
ANTONIN ARTAUD